Reality TV Figure’s Boyfriend Heads to Trial in Shocking South Florida Boating Case
A South Florida courtroom is set to take center stage this week as the boyfriend of a former “90 Day Fiancé” personality faces serious charges tied to a chaotic incident at a major boating event known as “Boca Bash.” What began as a day on the water has now evolved into a high-stakes attempted murder trial that has captured national attention.
Cole Goldberg was originally arrested on a charge of domestic battery by strangulation following the April 24, 2022 incident. More than a year later, authorities upgraded the charge to attempted second-degree murder, according to the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office. The escalation underscores just how seriously law enforcement is treating what unfolded during that fateful outing.
Heated Argument at “Boca Bash”
Investigators say Goldberg and his girlfriend at the time, Caroline Schwitzky, got into a fierce argument while attending Boca Bash, an annual boating gathering that draws large crowds off the South Florida coast. The couple had reportedly been dating for about a year when tensions boiled over.
Schwitzky, 32, is not just a reality TV alum — she is also the CEO of Miami-based talent agency Urge and a mother of three. She previously appeared on “90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After?” in 2016 as a talent agent to Paola Mayfield.
According to police reports, the verbal dispute allegedly turned physical as Schwitzky attempted to leave the boat. Authorities claim Goldberg aggressively grabbed her in an effort to stop her from getting away. The struggle reportedly stretched on for approximately 20 minutes.
- Schwitzky allegedly struck Goldberg on the arms in an attempt to free herself.
- She ultimately leapt into the water to escape the vessel.
- A witness said she swam toward a nearby boat in search of safety.
Allegations of Attempted Drowning
What prosecutors describe next forms the heart of the attempted murder charge. After Schwitzky jumped into the water, Goldberg allegedly followed her. Authorities claim he attempted to push her under the surface in what investigators believe was an effort to drown her.
A bystander, identified as Matt Paris, intervened by jumping into the water and pulling Goldberg away. His quick action may have prevented a tragic outcome.
Prosecutors argue the evidence shows a deliberate and dangerous escalation that could have cost a life.
From a festive public event to a fight for survival, the allegations paint a disturbing picture of how fast a domestic conflict can spiral out of control.
Plea Deal Rejected
According to courtroom reports, prosecutors offered Goldberg a plea agreement that would have required six months behind bars, three years of probation, and a written 500-word apology letter. However, Goldberg declined the deal, reportedly refusing to plead guilty to a felony offense.
By turning down the agreement, Goldberg is now opting to fight the more serious attempted second-degree murder charge at trial — a decision that could carry significant consequences if a jury convicts him.
The American justice system rests on the principle that every individual is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. That process now moves forward in Palm Beach County, where jurors will weigh testimony, evidence, and witness accounts from the high-profile Boca Bash confrontation.
This case also shines a spotlight on the broader issue of domestic violence and public safety. What should have been a sunny South Florida gathering ended in frightening allegations of violence on open water — a reminder that law and order must prevail wherever Americans gather.
As the trial begins, all eyes will be on the courtroom. The outcome will determine whether prosecutors have proven their case beyond a reasonable doubt — and whether justice is served for everyone involved.
